Many small business owners are surprised to learn that their website could be the subject of an accessibility complaint. Lawsuits and demand letters claiming that websites are inaccessible to people with disabilities have become common in the United States, and they are not limited to large companies. This article offers general background only. It is not legal advice. If you receive a demand letter or have concerns about your obligations, talk to a qualified lawyer.
The background
The Americans with Disabilities Act, passed in 1990, prohibits discrimination against people with disabilities, including in places of public accommodation such as stores, restaurants and offices. The law was written before websites were part of everyday business. Since then, courts have been asked whether and how it applies online, and outcomes have varied across different parts of the country. The U.S. Department of Justice has published guidance indicating that it views web accessibility as part of the ADA’s requirements for businesses open to the public. You can read its guidance on ada.gov.
Because the rules for private businesses’ websites have developed largely through court cases and guidance rather than a single detailed regulation, many businesses look to the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines, known as WCAG, as the practical benchmark.
What complaints often focus on
Claims commonly describe barriers that make a website hard to use with assistive technology, such as screen readers or keyboard-only navigation. Frequently cited issues include:
- Images without meaningful alternative text.
- Forms whose fields are not properly labeled.
- Menus or checkouts that cannot be operated with a keyboard.
- Text with too little contrast against its background.
- Videos without captions.
- Documents, such as PDF menus, that screen readers cannot read.
A word about overlay widgets
Some products promise to make a website accessible or compliant instantly by adding a toolbar or script. These tools can change some aspects of how a page displays, but they do not fix underlying problems in the site’s code and content. Accessibility advocates have criticized many of them, and installing one does not guarantee protection from claims. Treat any promise of instant compliance with caution.
Sensible steps to take
Accessibility is best approached as ongoing work rather than a one-time fix. Practical steps include:
- Have the website reviewed against WCAG by someone experienced, using both automated tools and manual testing.
- Prioritize fixing barriers on the pages that matter most, such as contact, booking and checkout.
- Build accessibility into new content: alt text for images, real headings, captions for videos and accessible documents.
- Publish an accessibility statement with a way for visitors to report problems and request help.
- Keep records of the work you do and when you did it.
If you receive a demand letter
Do not ignore it, and do not respond without advice. Contact a lawyer, ideally one familiar with accessibility claims, before replying or making payments. Share the letter with whoever manages your website so they can document the site’s current state. Most importantly, keep the bigger goal in mind. Making your website usable for everyone is good for customers, and it is the most durable protection there is.
What a Basic Accessibility Check Looks Like
A full review should be done by someone experienced, but owners can learn a lot about their own site in an afternoon. These checks will not catch everything, and they are not a substitute for a professional review, but they help you understand what reviewers look for.
- Put the mouse away. Use only the Tab, Shift+Tab and Enter keys to move through your home page, contact form and checkout. Can you reach every link and button? Can you see where you are on the page at each step?
- Zoom in. Increase your browser zoom significantly. Does the text reflow so you can still read it, or does content overlap or disappear?
- Look at your images. Ask whether each meaningful image has a short text description that conveys its purpose. Decorative images generally should not have descriptions that clutter a screen reader’s experience.
- Read your headings. Pages should use real heading levels in a logical order, not just large bold text. Screen reader users often navigate by headings.
- Check your forms. Each field should have a visible label that stays in place, and error messages should explain what went wrong in words, not only with a red outline.
- Play your videos. Are captions available and accurate?
- Open your documents. Menus, price sheets and brochures posted as scanned images or PDFs are a common barrier. Consider offering the same information as a regular web page.
Many operating systems include a built-in screen reader. Trying one for a few minutes on your own site can be eye-opening, even if you only get through the home page.
Mistakes Businesses Make When They Get Worried
- Relying only on an automated scanner. Automated tools are useful for catching some issues, such as missing labels or low contrast, but many barriers can only be found by a person testing the site.
- Fixing once and forgetting. New pages, photos, products and documents are added every month. Without good habits, a site that was improved last year can slip again.
- Overlooking third-party tools. Booking widgets, chat tools, payment pages and embedded maps are part of your visitors’ experience. Ask vendors about the accessibility of their products.
- Writing an accessibility statement that overpromises. A statement should describe your commitment and how people can get help, not claim the site is perfect.
Building Accessibility Into Everyday Work
The most effective protection is a routine. A short habit list, kept with your website documentation, helps everyone who edits the site:
- Write alt text when you upload an image, not later.
- Use the heading styles in your editor rather than making text bigger.
- Write link text that makes sense on its own, such as View our fall menu instead of click here.
- Caption videos before publishing them.
- Check contrast when choosing colors for buttons, banners and promotions.
- Test new forms and features with a keyboard before launch.
Questions Owners Ask
Is there a certificate that proves our site is compliant?
Be cautious of anyone offering one. An expert review can document how a site measures up against WCAG at a point in time, which is valuable, but websites change constantly. Records of ongoing work tend to be more meaningful than a single badge.
Where should we start if our budget is limited?
Start with the pages and tasks people need most: finding your contact information, booking, requesting a quote or buying. Fixing barriers there helps the most visitors first.
Does a new website automatically solve this?
Not automatically. Ask any designer or developer how they test for accessibility and what standard they work toward. Then keep good habits after launch, because content added later matters as much as the original build. For questions about your legal obligations, a lawyer is the right person to ask.



