Skip to main content Scroll Top

Sales Tax Settings in Online Stores: Questions to Ask Your Accountant

Sales tax is one of the less exciting parts of running an online store, and one of the easiest to get wrong. Store platforms include tax settings and often integrate with tax calculation services, but they cannot decide your obligations for you. They calculate based on how you configure them. This article explains the general landscape and the questions worth bringing to your accountant. It is not tax advice. Rules differ by location and change over time, so rely on a qualified tax professional for your specific situation.

Why online sales tax is complicated

In the United States, sales tax is set by states and often by local jurisdictions too. Rates and rules vary, and some products are taxed differently from others. Shipping charges may or may not be taxable depending on the location. For online sellers, an added question is where you have an obligation to collect tax at all.

That obligation, often called nexus, can come from having a physical presence in a state, such as a store, office, employees or inventory. Since a 2018 U.S. Supreme Court decision, South Dakota v. Wayfair, states may also require remote sellers to collect tax based on their sales into the state, even without a physical presence. Each state sets its own thresholds and rules. Selling through marketplaces adds another layer, since many states require marketplaces to collect tax on sales made through them.

Advertisement

What the platform settings control

Store tax settings typically let you specify:

  • Which locations you are registered to collect tax in.
  • Whether prices are displayed with or without tax included.
  • Whether shipping is taxed.
  • Tax categories or codes for products that are taxed differently.
  • Exemptions, such as for wholesale customers with valid certificates.
  • Whether rates are calculated automatically or entered manually.

Automated tax services can calculate rates by address, which is generally more accurate than entering rates by hand. Some also help with filing. Their usefulness still depends on accurate registration and product information.

Questions to ask your accountant

  • Where do we currently have an obligation to collect sales tax?
  • Which states’ remote seller thresholds might we be approaching, and how should we monitor them?
  • Are any of our products taxed differently or exempt in the places we sell?
  • Is shipping taxable in the locations where we collect?
  • How should marketplace sales be handled in our records?
  • How should wholesale or tax-exempt customers be documented?
  • Would an automated calculation or filing service make sense for us?

Testing your configuration

Once your accountant has advised you and the settings are configured, test them. Place test orders with addresses in different locations, with and without taxable shipping, and for products in different tax categories. Check that the tax shown at checkout matches what you expect. Repeat these checks when you add new product types, start selling in new places or change platforms.

Keep good records

Whatever your obligations, keep reports of sales and tax collected organized and easy to export. Most platforms provide tax reports, and your accountant will appreciate receiving them in a consistent format. Review your situation with your accountant periodically, especially as your sales grow into new areas.

Preparing for the Conversation

Your accountant can give better answers when you bring organized information. Before the meeting, gather:

Advertisement
  • Where you sell: your own website, marketplaces, in person, at events or through wholesale accounts.
  • Where your physical presence is: storefronts, offices, warehouses, employees, contractors and any inventory stored by others on your behalf.
  • Where your customers are: a report of sales by state, ideally covering the past year or more, with order counts as well as totals.
  • What you sell: a list of product types, especially anything unusual such as food, clothing, digital goods, services or subscriptions.
  • How you charge for shipping and handling: separately, built into prices or both.
  • Your current settings: screenshots of your store’s tax configuration so your accountant can see what is actually happening.

Most store platforms can export sales by location. If you are unsure how, your web professional can help you find or build the report.

A Practical Testing Routine

Once settings are in place, a structured test makes it easier to spot problems. Create a small set of test orders:

  1. An order shipped to an address in a location where you collect tax.
  2. An order shipped to an address where you do not collect tax.
  3. An order with a shipping charge, to see whether shipping is taxed as your accountant advised.
  4. An order containing a product in a different tax category, if you have any.
  5. An order with a discount code, to check that tax is calculated on the right amount.
  6. An order from a tax-exempt customer account, if you sell wholesale.

Write down the tax shown for each, compare with what you expected and share any surprises with your accountant before changing settings yourself.

Mistakes That Cause Headaches Later

  • Turning on tax everywhere just in case. Collecting tax where you are not registered can create its own problems. Collect where your accountant says you should.
  • Setting it and forgetting it. A growing store may cross thresholds in new places. Someone should watch sales by location over time.
  • Manual rates that go stale. Hand-entered rates do not update themselves when local rates change.
  • Uncategorized products. New products added without the right tax category may be taxed incorrectly.
  • Exemption certificates kept nowhere. If you sell to tax-exempt buyers, ask your accountant how to collect and store their documentation.
  • Platform changes without a retest. Moving to a new store platform or adding a tax app is a reason to run the test orders again.

Things to Put on the Calendar

  • A periodic review of sales by location with your accountant.
  • Filing deadlines for each place you are registered, as your accountant advises.
  • A retest of tax settings before each busy season and after any platform update that touches checkout.
  • A yearly check that your registrations, business address and contact details are current with each tax authority.

Questions Store Owners Ask

Does an automated tax service handle everything?

It can calculate rates accurately and, in some cases, help with filing, but it relies on you to tell it where you are registered and what your products are. Your accountant still advises on obligations.

Should prices include tax?

In the United States, prices are commonly shown before tax, with tax added at checkout. Whatever you choose, make it clear to shoppers and consistent across the site. Ask your accountant if you sell internationally.

Our clients